#151483: "Excess goods passing and discarding is unintuitive"
¿Sobre qué es este informe?
¿Qué ha pasado? Por favor, selecciona una de las opciones siguientes
¿Qué ha pasado? Por favor, selecciona una de las opciones siguientes
Por favor, comprueba si ya hay un informe sobre el mismo tema
Si es así, por favor VOTA por este informe. ¡A los informes con más votos se les da PRIORIDAD!
| # | Status | Votes | Game | Type | Title | Last update |
|---|
Descripción detallada
-
• Por favor, copia/pega el mensaje de error que ves en tu pantalla, si hay alguno.
I agree with the other posts I've seen that the process for giving and discarding excess goods is confusing and unintuitive. The main reasons are:
- The resources given appear in the fields. It would be better if these were moved below the player's board.
- There were times that my opponent had the same type of resource in both the storehouse and harvested goods. It wouldn't let him select the goods in the storehouse to discard. He had to select the goods in the field. There were times that it told him he had to discard more goods, even when he had selected the required number.
- The button should confirm the number of goods being passed/given, or have an option for 'skip discard'. It doesn't make sense to click a button that says 'Discard goods' when discarding none.
Proposed flow:
- When there are excess goods, move all harvested goods below the current player board.
- Prompt player to choose which goods to give. Allow selection from either storehouse or harvested goods.
- Change confirmation button to include a number counter (Give 1 good, Give 2 goods, etc...)
- Given goods are passed to the opponent and appear at the bottom of their board, NOT back in the fields. This is one of the most confusing parts as it is not easy to see what was passed.
- Prompt player to choose which goods to KEEP (not discard). If there is sufficient room, include button for 'Keep All Goods'.
- If player chooses more goods than there is capacity for, then the next prompt is to choose X number of goods to DISCARD.
- Change confirmation button to include a number counter to confirm number of goods discarded. (Discard 0 goods, Discard 1 good, Discard 2 goods, etc..) -
• Por favor, explica lo que querías hacer, lo que hiciste y lo que pasó
• ¿Qué navegador estás usando?
Google Chrome v131
-
• Por favor, copia/pega el texto mostrado en inglés en lugar de en tu idioma. Si tienes una captura de pantalla de este error (buena práctica), puedes usar un servicio de hospedaje de imágenes a tu elección (snipboard.io, por ejemplo) para subirla y copiar/pegar el enlace aquí. ¿Está este texto disponible en el sistema de traducción? Si es así, ¿ha sido traducido hace más de 24 horas?
I agree with the other posts I've seen that the process for giving and discarding excess goods is confusing and unintuitive. The main reasons are:
- The resources given appear in the fields. It would be better if these were moved below the player's board.
- There were times that my opponent had the same type of resource in both the storehouse and harvested goods. It wouldn't let him select the goods in the storehouse to discard. He had to select the goods in the field. There were times that it told him he had to discard more goods, even when he had selected the required number.
- The button should confirm the number of goods being passed/given, or have an option for 'skip discard'. It doesn't make sense to click a button that says 'Discard goods' when discarding none.
Proposed flow:
- When there are excess goods, move all harvested goods below the current player board.
- Prompt player to choose which goods to give. Allow selection from either storehouse or harvested goods.
- Change confirmation button to include a number counter (Give 1 good, Give 2 goods, etc...)
- Given goods are passed to the opponent and appear at the bottom of their board, NOT back in the fields. This is one of the most confusing parts as it is not easy to see what was passed.
- Prompt player to choose which goods to KEEP (not discard). If there is sufficient room, include button for 'Keep All Goods'.
- If player chooses more goods than there is capacity for, then the next prompt is to choose X number of goods to DISCARD.
- Change confirmation button to include a number counter to confirm number of goods discarded. (Discard 0 goods, Discard 1 good, Discard 2 goods, etc..) • ¿Qué navegador estás usando?
Google Chrome v131
-
• Por favor explica tu sugerencia de manera precisa y concisa para que sea lo más fácil posible entender lo que quieres decir.
I agree with the other posts I've seen that the process for giving and discarding excess goods is confusing and unintuitive. The main reasons are:
- The resources given appear in the fields. It would be better if these were moved below the player's board.
- There were times that my opponent had the same type of resource in both the storehouse and harvested goods. It wouldn't let him select the goods in the storehouse to discard. He had to select the goods in the field. There were times that it told him he had to discard more goods, even when he had selected the required number.
- The button should confirm the number of goods being passed/given, or have an option for 'skip discard'. It doesn't make sense to click a button that says 'Discard goods' when discarding none.
Proposed flow:
- When there are excess goods, move all harvested goods below the current player board.
- Prompt player to choose which goods to give. Allow selection from either storehouse or harvested goods.
- Change confirmation button to include a number counter (Give 1 good, Give 2 goods, etc...)
- Given goods are passed to the opponent and appear at the bottom of their board, NOT back in the fields. This is one of the most confusing parts as it is not easy to see what was passed.
- Prompt player to choose which goods to KEEP (not discard). If there is sufficient room, include button for 'Keep All Goods'.
- If player chooses more goods than there is capacity for, then the next prompt is to choose X number of goods to DISCARD.
- Change confirmation button to include a number counter to confirm number of goods discarded. (Discard 0 goods, Discard 1 good, Discard 2 goods, etc..) • ¿Qué navegador estás usando?
Google Chrome v131
-
• ¿Qué había en la pantalla cuando se quedó bloqueado? (¿mensaje de error?, ¿pantalla en blanco?, ¿una parte de la interfaz del juego?)
I agree with the other posts I've seen that the process for giving and discarding excess goods is confusing and unintuitive. The main reasons are:
- The resources given appear in the fields. It would be better if these were moved below the player's board.
- There were times that my opponent had the same type of resource in both the storehouse and harvested goods. It wouldn't let him select the goods in the storehouse to discard. He had to select the goods in the field. There were times that it told him he had to discard more goods, even when he had selected the required number.
- The button should confirm the number of goods being passed/given, or have an option for 'skip discard'. It doesn't make sense to click a button that says 'Discard goods' when discarding none.
Proposed flow:
- When there are excess goods, move all harvested goods below the current player board.
- Prompt player to choose which goods to give. Allow selection from either storehouse or harvested goods.
- Change confirmation button to include a number counter (Give 1 good, Give 2 goods, etc...)
- Given goods are passed to the opponent and appear at the bottom of their board, NOT back in the fields. This is one of the most confusing parts as it is not easy to see what was passed.
- Prompt player to choose which goods to KEEP (not discard). If there is sufficient room, include button for 'Keep All Goods'.
- If player chooses more goods than there is capacity for, then the next prompt is to choose X number of goods to DISCARD.
- Change confirmation button to include a number counter to confirm number of goods discarded. (Discard 0 goods, Discard 1 good, Discard 2 goods, etc..) • ¿Qué navegador estás usando?
Google Chrome v131
-
• ¿Qué parte de las reglas no se ha respetado en la adaptación de BGA?
I agree with the other posts I've seen that the process for giving and discarding excess goods is confusing and unintuitive. The main reasons are:
- The resources given appear in the fields. It would be better if these were moved below the player's board.
- There were times that my opponent had the same type of resource in both the storehouse and harvested goods. It wouldn't let him select the goods in the storehouse to discard. He had to select the goods in the field. There were times that it told him he had to discard more goods, even when he had selected the required number.
- The button should confirm the number of goods being passed/given, or have an option for 'skip discard'. It doesn't make sense to click a button that says 'Discard goods' when discarding none.
Proposed flow:
- When there are excess goods, move all harvested goods below the current player board.
- Prompt player to choose which goods to give. Allow selection from either storehouse or harvested goods.
- Change confirmation button to include a number counter (Give 1 good, Give 2 goods, etc...)
- Given goods are passed to the opponent and appear at the bottom of their board, NOT back in the fields. This is one of the most confusing parts as it is not easy to see what was passed.
- Prompt player to choose which goods to KEEP (not discard). If there is sufficient room, include button for 'Keep All Goods'.
- If player chooses more goods than there is capacity for, then the next prompt is to choose X number of goods to DISCARD.
- Change confirmation button to include a number counter to confirm number of goods discarded. (Discard 0 goods, Discard 1 good, Discard 2 goods, etc..) -
• ¿La infracción de las reglas es visible en la repetición de la partida? Si es así, ¿en qué jugada?
• ¿Qué navegador estás usando?
Google Chrome v131
-
• ¿Qué acción de juego querías realizar?
I agree with the other posts I've seen that the process for giving and discarding excess goods is confusing and unintuitive. The main reasons are:
- The resources given appear in the fields. It would be better if these were moved below the player's board.
- There were times that my opponent had the same type of resource in both the storehouse and harvested goods. It wouldn't let him select the goods in the storehouse to discard. He had to select the goods in the field. There were times that it told him he had to discard more goods, even when he had selected the required number.
- The button should confirm the number of goods being passed/given, or have an option for 'skip discard'. It doesn't make sense to click a button that says 'Discard goods' when discarding none.
Proposed flow:
- When there are excess goods, move all harvested goods below the current player board.
- Prompt player to choose which goods to give. Allow selection from either storehouse or harvested goods.
- Change confirmation button to include a number counter (Give 1 good, Give 2 goods, etc...)
- Given goods are passed to the opponent and appear at the bottom of their board, NOT back in the fields. This is one of the most confusing parts as it is not easy to see what was passed.
- Prompt player to choose which goods to KEEP (not discard). If there is sufficient room, include button for 'Keep All Goods'.
- If player chooses more goods than there is capacity for, then the next prompt is to choose X number of goods to DISCARD.
- Change confirmation button to include a number counter to confirm number of goods discarded. (Discard 0 goods, Discard 1 good, Discard 2 goods, etc..) -
• ¿Qué es lo que trataste de hacer para activar esta acción del juego?
-
• ¿Qué sucedió cuando lo hiciste (el mensaje de error, mensaje en la barra de estado del juego, ...)?
• ¿Qué navegador estás usando?
Google Chrome v131
-
• ¿En qué etapa de la partida ocurrió el problema? ¿Cuál era la instrucción actual del juego?
I agree with the other posts I've seen that the process for giving and discarding excess goods is confusing and unintuitive. The main reasons are:
- The resources given appear in the fields. It would be better if these were moved below the player's board.
- There were times that my opponent had the same type of resource in both the storehouse and harvested goods. It wouldn't let him select the goods in the storehouse to discard. He had to select the goods in the field. There were times that it told him he had to discard more goods, even when he had selected the required number.
- The button should confirm the number of goods being passed/given, or have an option for 'skip discard'. It doesn't make sense to click a button that says 'Discard goods' when discarding none.
Proposed flow:
- When there are excess goods, move all harvested goods below the current player board.
- Prompt player to choose which goods to give. Allow selection from either storehouse or harvested goods.
- Change confirmation button to include a number counter (Give 1 good, Give 2 goods, etc...)
- Given goods are passed to the opponent and appear at the bottom of their board, NOT back in the fields. This is one of the most confusing parts as it is not easy to see what was passed.
- Prompt player to choose which goods to KEEP (not discard). If there is sufficient room, include button for 'Keep All Goods'.
- If player chooses more goods than there is capacity for, then the next prompt is to choose X number of goods to DISCARD.
- Change confirmation button to include a number counter to confirm number of goods discarded. (Discard 0 goods, Discard 1 good, Discard 2 goods, etc..) -
• ¿Qué sucedió cuando trataste de hacer una acción de juego (mensaje de error, mensaje en la barra de estado del juego, ...)?
• ¿Qué navegador estás usando?
Google Chrome v131
-
• Por favor, describe el problema de visualización. Si tienes una captura de pantalla de este error (buena práctica), puedes usar un servicio de hospedaje de imágenes a tu elección (snipboard.io, por ejemplo) para subirla y copiar/pegar el enlace aquí.
I agree with the other posts I've seen that the process for giving and discarding excess goods is confusing and unintuitive. The main reasons are:
- The resources given appear in the fields. It would be better if these were moved below the player's board.
- There were times that my opponent had the same type of resource in both the storehouse and harvested goods. It wouldn't let him select the goods in the storehouse to discard. He had to select the goods in the field. There were times that it told him he had to discard more goods, even when he had selected the required number.
- The button should confirm the number of goods being passed/given, or have an option for 'skip discard'. It doesn't make sense to click a button that says 'Discard goods' when discarding none.
Proposed flow:
- When there are excess goods, move all harvested goods below the current player board.
- Prompt player to choose which goods to give. Allow selection from either storehouse or harvested goods.
- Change confirmation button to include a number counter (Give 1 good, Give 2 goods, etc...)
- Given goods are passed to the opponent and appear at the bottom of their board, NOT back in the fields. This is one of the most confusing parts as it is not easy to see what was passed.
- Prompt player to choose which goods to KEEP (not discard). If there is sufficient room, include button for 'Keep All Goods'.
- If player chooses more goods than there is capacity for, then the next prompt is to choose X number of goods to DISCARD.
- Change confirmation button to include a number counter to confirm number of goods discarded. (Discard 0 goods, Discard 1 good, Discard 2 goods, etc..) • ¿Qué navegador estás usando?
Google Chrome v131
-
• Por favor, copia/pega el texto mostrado en inglés en lugar de en tu idioma. Si tienes una captura de pantalla de este error (buena práctica), puedes usar un servicio de hospedaje de imágenes a tu elección (snipboard.io, por ejemplo) para subirla y copiar/pegar el enlace aquí. ¿Está este texto disponible en el sistema de traducción? Si es así, ¿ha sido traducido hace más de 24 horas?
I agree with the other posts I've seen that the process for giving and discarding excess goods is confusing and unintuitive. The main reasons are:
- The resources given appear in the fields. It would be better if these were moved below the player's board.
- There were times that my opponent had the same type of resource in both the storehouse and harvested goods. It wouldn't let him select the goods in the storehouse to discard. He had to select the goods in the field. There were times that it told him he had to discard more goods, even when he had selected the required number.
- The button should confirm the number of goods being passed/given, or have an option for 'skip discard'. It doesn't make sense to click a button that says 'Discard goods' when discarding none.
Proposed flow:
- When there are excess goods, move all harvested goods below the current player board.
- Prompt player to choose which goods to give. Allow selection from either storehouse or harvested goods.
- Change confirmation button to include a number counter (Give 1 good, Give 2 goods, etc...)
- Given goods are passed to the opponent and appear at the bottom of their board, NOT back in the fields. This is one of the most confusing parts as it is not easy to see what was passed.
- Prompt player to choose which goods to KEEP (not discard). If there is sufficient room, include button for 'Keep All Goods'.
- If player chooses more goods than there is capacity for, then the next prompt is to choose X number of goods to DISCARD.
- Change confirmation button to include a number counter to confirm number of goods discarded. (Discard 0 goods, Discard 1 good, Discard 2 goods, etc..) • ¿Qué navegador estás usando?
Google Chrome v131
-
• Por favor explica tu sugerencia de manera precisa y concisa para que sea lo más fácil posible entender lo que quieres decir.
I agree with the other posts I've seen that the process for giving and discarding excess goods is confusing and unintuitive. The main reasons are:
- The resources given appear in the fields. It would be better if these were moved below the player's board.
- There were times that my opponent had the same type of resource in both the storehouse and harvested goods. It wouldn't let him select the goods in the storehouse to discard. He had to select the goods in the field. There were times that it told him he had to discard more goods, even when he had selected the required number.
- The button should confirm the number of goods being passed/given, or have an option for 'skip discard'. It doesn't make sense to click a button that says 'Discard goods' when discarding none.
Proposed flow:
- When there are excess goods, move all harvested goods below the current player board.
- Prompt player to choose which goods to give. Allow selection from either storehouse or harvested goods.
- Change confirmation button to include a number counter (Give 1 good, Give 2 goods, etc...)
- Given goods are passed to the opponent and appear at the bottom of their board, NOT back in the fields. This is one of the most confusing parts as it is not easy to see what was passed.
- Prompt player to choose which goods to KEEP (not discard). If there is sufficient room, include button for 'Keep All Goods'.
- If player chooses more goods than there is capacity for, then the next prompt is to choose X number of goods to DISCARD.
- Change confirmation button to include a number counter to confirm number of goods discarded. (Discard 0 goods, Discard 1 good, Discard 2 goods, etc..) • ¿Qué navegador estás usando?
Google Chrome v131
Historial de informes
The goods remain in the fields because of the lack of space.
It's always better than making things tinier or scrolling all the time.
They are close to the stores and it's easy to focus on what you need.
Yellow surroundings are easy to see.
You cannot select tokens in your stores in the discarding part because... these are the rules.
I cannot write the exact number of resources to discard because it can be different if you have extra waters store.
I have chosen Discard instead of Keep because there are less clicks to be done.
Agregar a este informe
- Otro ID de partida / ID de jugada
- ¿Se resolvió el problema al pulsar F5?
- ¿Apareció el problema varias veces? ¿Cada vez? ¿Aleatoriamente?
- Si tienes una captura de pantalla de este error (buena práctica), puedes usar un servicio de hospedaje de imágenes a tu elección (snipboard.io, por ejemplo) para subirla y copiar/pegar el enlace aquí.
