#40805: "General suggestions after playing first Alpha game (3-player)"
¿Sobre qué es este informe?
¿Qué ha pasado? Por favor, selecciona una de las opciones siguientes
¿Qué ha pasado? Por favor, selecciona una de las opciones siguientes
Por favor, comprueba si ya hay un informe sobre el mismo tema
Si es así, por favor VOTA por este informe. ¡A los informes con más votos se les da PRIORIDAD!
| # | Status | Votes | Game | Type | Title | Last update |
|---|
Descripción detallada
-
• Por favor, copia/pega el mensaje de error que ves en tu pantalla, si hay alguno.
First impression - The game is great! This is one of my daughter's favorites and it gets played all the time at our house.
I ran through a few 3-player games (pseudo real-time) with family. Here are my initial comments:
- If you change your mind on your bid before everyone has submitted theirs, you should be able to simply click on the new donut or bid card without pressing Remote Bid first. The remove bid is fine as an Undo, but I should be able to quickly click a different donut. See 6 nimmit! as an example.
- Recommend splaying the donut cards in front of each player instead of putting a number on them when there are multiple cards. Just down and to the right a little bit. The game moves fast when at real-time and it is much easier to quickly tell a player has 3 jelly-filled already when scrolling down if they are splayed out.
- When selecting a target player, in addition to the buttons at the top with their name on it, it would be nice to be able to select their player board (the box with their name and score) or by clicking on their table of donuts. So if I scroll down to see who I want to give it to, I would be able to just click on that display.
- I noticed that when another player was making a decision, I didn't always have a message at the top telling me what was happening. In a real-time game it is really quick and probably not an issue, but I could see it causing an issue in turn-based. What is the game waiting for? I noticed this on Double Chocolate when the player was selecting between the two cards, and on red velvet when the player was selecting a card from the discard pile.
- Recommend adding a button that when pressed displays the "Donut Guide" from the manual on the screen. Similar to Kingdomino that has a button to display the a tile guide.
- There may be an issue with the scoring. One moment the scores were 11,11,10 and then after the very next round I noticed it was 24,20.16. That got me trying to pay attention to the scoring, but it is hard in a psuedo-realtime game. At the end of our last game I manually calculated the scores and they all seemed fine. I'll try and watch this more.
Overall, I think this game is nearly ready for Beta. I'm going to try and get a larger player count game going with some friends. I think this game will get a lot of usage on BGA. Awesome work. -
• Por favor, explica lo que querías hacer, lo que hiciste y lo que pasó
• ¿Qué navegador estás usando?
Google Chrome v90
-
• Por favor, copia/pega el texto mostrado en inglés en lugar de en tu idioma. Si tienes una captura de este error (buena práctica), puedes usar Imgur.com para subirla y copiar/pegar el enlace aquí.
First impression - The game is great! This is one of my daughter's favorites and it gets played all the time at our house.
I ran through a few 3-player games (pseudo real-time) with family. Here are my initial comments:
- If you change your mind on your bid before everyone has submitted theirs, you should be able to simply click on the new donut or bid card without pressing Remote Bid first. The remove bid is fine as an Undo, but I should be able to quickly click a different donut. See 6 nimmit! as an example.
- Recommend splaying the donut cards in front of each player instead of putting a number on them when there are multiple cards. Just down and to the right a little bit. The game moves fast when at real-time and it is much easier to quickly tell a player has 3 jelly-filled already when scrolling down if they are splayed out.
- When selecting a target player, in addition to the buttons at the top with their name on it, it would be nice to be able to select their player board (the box with their name and score) or by clicking on their table of donuts. So if I scroll down to see who I want to give it to, I would be able to just click on that display.
- I noticed that when another player was making a decision, I didn't always have a message at the top telling me what was happening. In a real-time game it is really quick and probably not an issue, but I could see it causing an issue in turn-based. What is the game waiting for? I noticed this on Double Chocolate when the player was selecting between the two cards, and on red velvet when the player was selecting a card from the discard pile.
- Recommend adding a button that when pressed displays the "Donut Guide" from the manual on the screen. Similar to Kingdomino that has a button to display the a tile guide.
- There may be an issue with the scoring. One moment the scores were 11,11,10 and then after the very next round I noticed it was 24,20.16. That got me trying to pay attention to the scoring, but it is hard in a psuedo-realtime game. At the end of our last game I manually calculated the scores and they all seemed fine. I'll try and watch this more.
Overall, I think this game is nearly ready for Beta. I'm going to try and get a larger player count game going with some friends. I think this game will get a lot of usage on BGA. Awesome work. -
• ¿Está este texto disponible en el sistema de traducción? Si es así, ¿ha sido traducido hace más de 24 horas?
• ¿Qué navegador estás usando?
Google Chrome v90
-
• Por favor explica tu sugerencia de manera precisa y concisa para que sea lo más fácil posible entender lo que quieres decir.
First impression - The game is great! This is one of my daughter's favorites and it gets played all the time at our house.
I ran through a few 3-player games (pseudo real-time) with family. Here are my initial comments:
- If you change your mind on your bid before everyone has submitted theirs, you should be able to simply click on the new donut or bid card without pressing Remote Bid first. The remove bid is fine as an Undo, but I should be able to quickly click a different donut. See 6 nimmit! as an example.
- Recommend splaying the donut cards in front of each player instead of putting a number on them when there are multiple cards. Just down and to the right a little bit. The game moves fast when at real-time and it is much easier to quickly tell a player has 3 jelly-filled already when scrolling down if they are splayed out.
- When selecting a target player, in addition to the buttons at the top with their name on it, it would be nice to be able to select their player board (the box with their name and score) or by clicking on their table of donuts. So if I scroll down to see who I want to give it to, I would be able to just click on that display.
- I noticed that when another player was making a decision, I didn't always have a message at the top telling me what was happening. In a real-time game it is really quick and probably not an issue, but I could see it causing an issue in turn-based. What is the game waiting for? I noticed this on Double Chocolate when the player was selecting between the two cards, and on red velvet when the player was selecting a card from the discard pile.
- Recommend adding a button that when pressed displays the "Donut Guide" from the manual on the screen. Similar to Kingdomino that has a button to display the a tile guide.
- There may be an issue with the scoring. One moment the scores were 11,11,10 and then after the very next round I noticed it was 24,20.16. That got me trying to pay attention to the scoring, but it is hard in a psuedo-realtime game. At the end of our last game I manually calculated the scores and they all seemed fine. I'll try and watch this more.
Overall, I think this game is nearly ready for Beta. I'm going to try and get a larger player count game going with some friends. I think this game will get a lot of usage on BGA. Awesome work. • ¿Qué navegador estás usando?
Google Chrome v90
-
• ¿Qué había en la pantalla cuando se quedó bloqueado? (¿mensaje de error?, ¿pantalla en blanco?, ¿una parte de la interfaz del juego?)
First impression - The game is great! This is one of my daughter's favorites and it gets played all the time at our house.
I ran through a few 3-player games (pseudo real-time) with family. Here are my initial comments:
- If you change your mind on your bid before everyone has submitted theirs, you should be able to simply click on the new donut or bid card without pressing Remote Bid first. The remove bid is fine as an Undo, but I should be able to quickly click a different donut. See 6 nimmit! as an example.
- Recommend splaying the donut cards in front of each player instead of putting a number on them when there are multiple cards. Just down and to the right a little bit. The game moves fast when at real-time and it is much easier to quickly tell a player has 3 jelly-filled already when scrolling down if they are splayed out.
- When selecting a target player, in addition to the buttons at the top with their name on it, it would be nice to be able to select their player board (the box with their name and score) or by clicking on their table of donuts. So if I scroll down to see who I want to give it to, I would be able to just click on that display.
- I noticed that when another player was making a decision, I didn't always have a message at the top telling me what was happening. In a real-time game it is really quick and probably not an issue, but I could see it causing an issue in turn-based. What is the game waiting for? I noticed this on Double Chocolate when the player was selecting between the two cards, and on red velvet when the player was selecting a card from the discard pile.
- Recommend adding a button that when pressed displays the "Donut Guide" from the manual on the screen. Similar to Kingdomino that has a button to display the a tile guide.
- There may be an issue with the scoring. One moment the scores were 11,11,10 and then after the very next round I noticed it was 24,20.16. That got me trying to pay attention to the scoring, but it is hard in a psuedo-realtime game. At the end of our last game I manually calculated the scores and they all seemed fine. I'll try and watch this more.
Overall, I think this game is nearly ready for Beta. I'm going to try and get a larger player count game going with some friends. I think this game will get a lot of usage on BGA. Awesome work. • ¿Qué navegador estás usando?
Google Chrome v90
-
• ¿Qué parte de las reglas no se ha respetado en la adaptación de BGA?
First impression - The game is great! This is one of my daughter's favorites and it gets played all the time at our house.
I ran through a few 3-player games (pseudo real-time) with family. Here are my initial comments:
- If you change your mind on your bid before everyone has submitted theirs, you should be able to simply click on the new donut or bid card without pressing Remote Bid first. The remove bid is fine as an Undo, but I should be able to quickly click a different donut. See 6 nimmit! as an example.
- Recommend splaying the donut cards in front of each player instead of putting a number on them when there are multiple cards. Just down and to the right a little bit. The game moves fast when at real-time and it is much easier to quickly tell a player has 3 jelly-filled already when scrolling down if they are splayed out.
- When selecting a target player, in addition to the buttons at the top with their name on it, it would be nice to be able to select their player board (the box with their name and score) or by clicking on their table of donuts. So if I scroll down to see who I want to give it to, I would be able to just click on that display.
- I noticed that when another player was making a decision, I didn't always have a message at the top telling me what was happening. In a real-time game it is really quick and probably not an issue, but I could see it causing an issue in turn-based. What is the game waiting for? I noticed this on Double Chocolate when the player was selecting between the two cards, and on red velvet when the player was selecting a card from the discard pile.
- Recommend adding a button that when pressed displays the "Donut Guide" from the manual on the screen. Similar to Kingdomino that has a button to display the a tile guide.
- There may be an issue with the scoring. One moment the scores were 11,11,10 and then after the very next round I noticed it was 24,20.16. That got me trying to pay attention to the scoring, but it is hard in a psuedo-realtime game. At the end of our last game I manually calculated the scores and they all seemed fine. I'll try and watch this more.
Overall, I think this game is nearly ready for Beta. I'm going to try and get a larger player count game going with some friends. I think this game will get a lot of usage on BGA. Awesome work. -
• ¿La infracción de las reglas es visible en la repetición de la partida? Si es así, ¿en qué jugada?
• ¿Qué navegador estás usando?
Google Chrome v90
-
• ¿Qué acción de juego querías realizar?
First impression - The game is great! This is one of my daughter's favorites and it gets played all the time at our house.
I ran through a few 3-player games (pseudo real-time) with family. Here are my initial comments:
- If you change your mind on your bid before everyone has submitted theirs, you should be able to simply click on the new donut or bid card without pressing Remote Bid first. The remove bid is fine as an Undo, but I should be able to quickly click a different donut. See 6 nimmit! as an example.
- Recommend splaying the donut cards in front of each player instead of putting a number on them when there are multiple cards. Just down and to the right a little bit. The game moves fast when at real-time and it is much easier to quickly tell a player has 3 jelly-filled already when scrolling down if they are splayed out.
- When selecting a target player, in addition to the buttons at the top with their name on it, it would be nice to be able to select their player board (the box with their name and score) or by clicking on their table of donuts. So if I scroll down to see who I want to give it to, I would be able to just click on that display.
- I noticed that when another player was making a decision, I didn't always have a message at the top telling me what was happening. In a real-time game it is really quick and probably not an issue, but I could see it causing an issue in turn-based. What is the game waiting for? I noticed this on Double Chocolate when the player was selecting between the two cards, and on red velvet when the player was selecting a card from the discard pile.
- Recommend adding a button that when pressed displays the "Donut Guide" from the manual on the screen. Similar to Kingdomino that has a button to display the a tile guide.
- There may be an issue with the scoring. One moment the scores were 11,11,10 and then after the very next round I noticed it was 24,20.16. That got me trying to pay attention to the scoring, but it is hard in a psuedo-realtime game. At the end of our last game I manually calculated the scores and they all seemed fine. I'll try and watch this more.
Overall, I think this game is nearly ready for Beta. I'm going to try and get a larger player count game going with some friends. I think this game will get a lot of usage on BGA. Awesome work. -
• ¿Qué es lo que trataste de hacer para activar esta acción del juego?
-
• ¿Qué sucedió cuando lo hiciste (el mensaje de error, mensaje en la barra de estado del juego, ...)?
• ¿Qué navegador estás usando?
Google Chrome v90
-
• ¿En qué etapa de la partida ocurrió el problema? ¿Cuál era la instrucción actual del juego?
First impression - The game is great! This is one of my daughter's favorites and it gets played all the time at our house.
I ran through a few 3-player games (pseudo real-time) with family. Here are my initial comments:
- If you change your mind on your bid before everyone has submitted theirs, you should be able to simply click on the new donut or bid card without pressing Remote Bid first. The remove bid is fine as an Undo, but I should be able to quickly click a different donut. See 6 nimmit! as an example.
- Recommend splaying the donut cards in front of each player instead of putting a number on them when there are multiple cards. Just down and to the right a little bit. The game moves fast when at real-time and it is much easier to quickly tell a player has 3 jelly-filled already when scrolling down if they are splayed out.
- When selecting a target player, in addition to the buttons at the top with their name on it, it would be nice to be able to select their player board (the box with their name and score) or by clicking on their table of donuts. So if I scroll down to see who I want to give it to, I would be able to just click on that display.
- I noticed that when another player was making a decision, I didn't always have a message at the top telling me what was happening. In a real-time game it is really quick and probably not an issue, but I could see it causing an issue in turn-based. What is the game waiting for? I noticed this on Double Chocolate when the player was selecting between the two cards, and on red velvet when the player was selecting a card from the discard pile.
- Recommend adding a button that when pressed displays the "Donut Guide" from the manual on the screen. Similar to Kingdomino that has a button to display the a tile guide.
- There may be an issue with the scoring. One moment the scores were 11,11,10 and then after the very next round I noticed it was 24,20.16. That got me trying to pay attention to the scoring, but it is hard in a psuedo-realtime game. At the end of our last game I manually calculated the scores and they all seemed fine. I'll try and watch this more.
Overall, I think this game is nearly ready for Beta. I'm going to try and get a larger player count game going with some friends. I think this game will get a lot of usage on BGA. Awesome work. -
• ¿Qué sucedió cuando trataste de hacer una acción de juego (mensaje de error, mensaje en la barra de estado del juego, ...)?
• ¿Qué navegador estás usando?
Google Chrome v90
-
• Por favor, describe el problema de visualización. Si tienes una captura de este error (buena práctica), puedes usar Imgur.com para subirla y copiar/pegar el enlace aquí.
First impression - The game is great! This is one of my daughter's favorites and it gets played all the time at our house.
I ran through a few 3-player games (pseudo real-time) with family. Here are my initial comments:
- If you change your mind on your bid before everyone has submitted theirs, you should be able to simply click on the new donut or bid card without pressing Remote Bid first. The remove bid is fine as an Undo, but I should be able to quickly click a different donut. See 6 nimmit! as an example.
- Recommend splaying the donut cards in front of each player instead of putting a number on them when there are multiple cards. Just down and to the right a little bit. The game moves fast when at real-time and it is much easier to quickly tell a player has 3 jelly-filled already when scrolling down if they are splayed out.
- When selecting a target player, in addition to the buttons at the top with their name on it, it would be nice to be able to select their player board (the box with their name and score) or by clicking on their table of donuts. So if I scroll down to see who I want to give it to, I would be able to just click on that display.
- I noticed that when another player was making a decision, I didn't always have a message at the top telling me what was happening. In a real-time game it is really quick and probably not an issue, but I could see it causing an issue in turn-based. What is the game waiting for? I noticed this on Double Chocolate when the player was selecting between the two cards, and on red velvet when the player was selecting a card from the discard pile.
- Recommend adding a button that when pressed displays the "Donut Guide" from the manual on the screen. Similar to Kingdomino that has a button to display the a tile guide.
- There may be an issue with the scoring. One moment the scores were 11,11,10 and then after the very next round I noticed it was 24,20.16. That got me trying to pay attention to the scoring, but it is hard in a psuedo-realtime game. At the end of our last game I manually calculated the scores and they all seemed fine. I'll try and watch this more.
Overall, I think this game is nearly ready for Beta. I'm going to try and get a larger player count game going with some friends. I think this game will get a lot of usage on BGA. Awesome work. • ¿Qué navegador estás usando?
Google Chrome v90
-
• Por favor, copia/pega el texto mostrado en inglés en lugar de en tu idioma. Si tienes una captura de este error (buena práctica), puedes usar Imgur.com para subirla y copiar/pegar el enlace aquí.
First impression - The game is great! This is one of my daughter's favorites and it gets played all the time at our house.
I ran through a few 3-player games (pseudo real-time) with family. Here are my initial comments:
- If you change your mind on your bid before everyone has submitted theirs, you should be able to simply click on the new donut or bid card without pressing Remote Bid first. The remove bid is fine as an Undo, but I should be able to quickly click a different donut. See 6 nimmit! as an example.
- Recommend splaying the donut cards in front of each player instead of putting a number on them when there are multiple cards. Just down and to the right a little bit. The game moves fast when at real-time and it is much easier to quickly tell a player has 3 jelly-filled already when scrolling down if they are splayed out.
- When selecting a target player, in addition to the buttons at the top with their name on it, it would be nice to be able to select their player board (the box with their name and score) or by clicking on their table of donuts. So if I scroll down to see who I want to give it to, I would be able to just click on that display.
- I noticed that when another player was making a decision, I didn't always have a message at the top telling me what was happening. In a real-time game it is really quick and probably not an issue, but I could see it causing an issue in turn-based. What is the game waiting for? I noticed this on Double Chocolate when the player was selecting between the two cards, and on red velvet when the player was selecting a card from the discard pile.
- Recommend adding a button that when pressed displays the "Donut Guide" from the manual on the screen. Similar to Kingdomino that has a button to display the a tile guide.
- There may be an issue with the scoring. One moment the scores were 11,11,10 and then after the very next round I noticed it was 24,20.16. That got me trying to pay attention to the scoring, but it is hard in a psuedo-realtime game. At the end of our last game I manually calculated the scores and they all seemed fine. I'll try and watch this more.
Overall, I think this game is nearly ready for Beta. I'm going to try and get a larger player count game going with some friends. I think this game will get a lot of usage on BGA. Awesome work. -
• ¿Está este texto disponible en el sistema de traducción? Si es así, ¿ha sido traducido hace más de 24 horas?
• ¿Qué navegador estás usando?
Google Chrome v90
-
• Por favor explica tu sugerencia de manera precisa y concisa para que sea lo más fácil posible entender lo que quieres decir.
First impression - The game is great! This is one of my daughter's favorites and it gets played all the time at our house.
I ran through a few 3-player games (pseudo real-time) with family. Here are my initial comments:
- If you change your mind on your bid before everyone has submitted theirs, you should be able to simply click on the new donut or bid card without pressing Remote Bid first. The remove bid is fine as an Undo, but I should be able to quickly click a different donut. See 6 nimmit! as an example.
- Recommend splaying the donut cards in front of each player instead of putting a number on them when there are multiple cards. Just down and to the right a little bit. The game moves fast when at real-time and it is much easier to quickly tell a player has 3 jelly-filled already when scrolling down if they are splayed out.
- When selecting a target player, in addition to the buttons at the top with their name on it, it would be nice to be able to select their player board (the box with their name and score) or by clicking on their table of donuts. So if I scroll down to see who I want to give it to, I would be able to just click on that display.
- I noticed that when another player was making a decision, I didn't always have a message at the top telling me what was happening. In a real-time game it is really quick and probably not an issue, but I could see it causing an issue in turn-based. What is the game waiting for? I noticed this on Double Chocolate when the player was selecting between the two cards, and on red velvet when the player was selecting a card from the discard pile.
- Recommend adding a button that when pressed displays the "Donut Guide" from the manual on the screen. Similar to Kingdomino that has a button to display the a tile guide.
- There may be an issue with the scoring. One moment the scores were 11,11,10 and then after the very next round I noticed it was 24,20.16. That got me trying to pay attention to the scoring, but it is hard in a psuedo-realtime game. At the end of our last game I manually calculated the scores and they all seemed fine. I'll try and watch this more.
Overall, I think this game is nearly ready for Beta. I'm going to try and get a larger player count game going with some friends. I think this game will get a lot of usage on BGA. Awesome work. • ¿Qué navegador estás usando?
Google Chrome v90
Historial de informes
Though I did notice that if the window shrinks, it doesn't shrink the cards. Instead it overlaps and becomes messy. And the it should move the player boards to the top based on minWidth setting. See screenshot:
drive.google.com/file/d/1w_LZ5KW4dV_fD6UglOks_Z_dmKkTz9tG/view
Agregar a este informe
- Otro ID de partida / ID de jugada
- ¿Se resolvió el problema al pulsar F5?
- ¿Apareció el problema varias veces? ¿Cada vez? ¿Aleatoriamente?
- Si tienes una captura de este error (buena práctica), puedes usar Imgur.com para subirla y copiar/pegar el enlace aquí.
