Todos los informes
#48711: "RED THUMBS should be disabled in Arena."
awaiting: Esta sugerencia aún no ha sido analizada por los desarrolladores
¿Sobre qué es este informe?
Página web de BGA
¿Qué ha pasado? Por favor, selecciona una de las opciones siguientes
Sugerencia: en mi opinión, lo siguiente mejoraría enormemente la página web
Descripción detallada
• Por favor explica tu sugerencia de manera precisa y concisa para que sea lo más fácil posible entender lo que quieres decir.
In a fair competition players can not select their opponents.• ¿Qué navegador estás usando?
Google Chrome v93
Historial de informes
18 sep 2021 10:51 • Countess-Aleksey • Esta sugerencia aún no ha sido analizada por los desarrolladores:
*
19 sep 2021 2:51 • ufm • Esta sugerencia aún no ha sido analizada por los desarrolladores:
While there are players handing out red thumbs only to preserve ranking (I've seen some), red thumb also prevents kingmakers, multiple accounts, cheaters, verbal offenders, or other miscreants from being matched together. It's a complex problem...
19 sep 2021 13:10 • Countess-Aleksey • Esta sugerencia aún no ha sido analizada por los desarrolladores:
How can playing in the Arena be fair, when you can give out RED THUMBS, view who has joined a game and last of all start a New Season on a higher level?
25 sep 2021 19:24 • ufm • Esta sugerencia aún no ha sido analizada por los desarrolladores:
I didn't say current system is 100% fair. I said voiding red thumb would not make Arena fairer.
27 sep 2021 23:06 • RedAlert39 • Esta sugerencia aún no ha sido analizada por los desarrolladores:
+1. Giving red thumbs doesn't prevent people from kingmaking, etc - it just prevents you personally from being matched with them, which does nothing to affect the overall fairness of arena matchmaking.
11 oct 2021 20:03 • Tybus913 • Esta sugerencia aún no ha sido analizada por los desarrolladores:
Agree with ufm. One of the reasons I give out red thumbs is if someone quits mid-game. I don't want to waste my time having to play those people.
9 dic 2021 13:00 • frankenStain • Esta sugerencia aún no ha sido analizada por los desarrolladores:
agree except for team based games (like tichu) , so its possible to avoid being teamed up with horendous partners - also to avoid cheaters (which also happens in tichu)
10 jun 2022 12:03 • FHenker • Esta sugerencia aún no ha sido analizada por los desarrolladores:
This exploit was extensively used by Sussuarana Onitama last season to try to steal the #1 ranking in Onitama: by giving red thumbs to me (and potentially other strong players), he biased the matchmaking to such an extent that I estimate his arena rating to have been inflated by at least 100-150 points in some moments!
At least in 1v1 games, there is NO reason why Arena matchmaking should take red thumbs into account — it opens up room for manipulation and cheating, and we have this very concrete example in Onitama!!
At least in 1v1 games, there is NO reason why Arena matchmaking should take red thumbs into account — it opens up room for manipulation and cheating, and we have this very concrete example in Onitama!!
23 oct 2023 9:30 • Sjarmtrollet • Esta sugerencia aún no ha sido analizada por los desarrolladores:
So very strange that red thumbs would impact arena matchmaking....that I would never assume.
27 may 2024 8:23 • Malo77 • Esta sugerencia aún no ha sido analizada por los desarrolladores:
RT system needs improvement, there are some RT abusers.
Limit nb of RT per day/week, and or timelimit them so a review every 1-2-3 month is needed to keep them or remove them by default.
Limit nb of RT per day/week, and or timelimit them so a review every 1-2-3 month is needed to keep them or remove them by default.
23 jul 2024 19:40 • Pechnik • Esta sugerencia aún no ha sido analizada por los desarrolladores:
Red thumbs are obviously a method of unfair competition that many players on this site use, especially in less popular games. It's a shame that the site allows this.
15 dic 2024 13:30 • RazorOz • Esta sugerencia aún no ha sido analizada por los desarrolladores:
Problem is the solution is complex. I could only get on board with something like this if the penalties for quitting an Arena game were significantly higher than they are now, because otherwise for players not abusing the red thumb for competition purposes, and instead using it as I would assume its attended this will be beyond tedious.
Because I don't want to play the army of players who think it's ok to play for an hour and quit on the last turn when they know they have lost that exist for certain games. If the penalties for such behaviour were harsher then this would make sense, but otherwise it's untenable to me.
The other issue is some of the other actions taken encourage using the red thumb for other reasons. Again, it's not something I do, but I can understand why players red thumb players they don't want to play because of the ELO reducer, because games where you can't win ELO, only lose are also tedious. This issue is one that could easily be fixed by going back to how it used to be, but so far BGA have stood by this change, which will lead to more behaviour like this.
Because I don't want to play the army of players who think it's ok to play for an hour and quit on the last turn when they know they have lost that exist for certain games. If the penalties for such behaviour were harsher then this would make sense, but otherwise it's untenable to me.
The other issue is some of the other actions taken encourage using the red thumb for other reasons. Again, it's not something I do, but I can understand why players red thumb players they don't want to play because of the ELO reducer, because games where you can't win ELO, only lose are also tedious. This issue is one that could easily be fixed by going back to how it used to be, but so far BGA have stood by this change, which will lead to more behaviour like this.
9 mar 2025 9:00 • yuniboshi • Esta sugerencia aún no ha sido analizada por los desarrolladores:
"red thumb also prevents kingmakers, multiple accounts, cheaters, verbal offenders, or other miscreants from being matched"
It does not. As long as BGA refuse to moderate these players (you cannot even report them - site tells you to "Red thumb" them instead) they will continue to exist because there will always be a next victim and because making new accounts to manipulate rating with is free. Competitive integrity is not gained by letting people choose to not play with cheaters, it is only gained by removing cheaters and bad sport from the pool and so is a bad reason to keep red thumbs in arena.
It does not. As long as BGA refuse to moderate these players (you cannot even report them - site tells you to "Red thumb" them instead) they will continue to exist because there will always be a next victim and because making new accounts to manipulate rating with is free. Competitive integrity is not gained by letting people choose to not play with cheaters, it is only gained by removing cheaters and bad sport from the pool and so is a bad reason to keep red thumbs in arena.
29 mar 2025 8:33 • NaCl_duke • Esta sugerencia aún no ha sido analizada por los desarrolladores:
Tactical red thumbing has gotten so bad at Tapestry that one player can block the formation of real time arena tables.They start an arena table but since they have almost everybody on red thumb nobody else can start a new table. If you do not want to play with certain players, fine, but why can I not start a separate arena table? My progress bar is stuck at "Searching for players..." never goes to "Searching for 1 player...."
9 jun 2025 0:24 • Le007n • Esta sugerencia aún no ha sido analizada por los desarrolladores:
Can we get an update on the dev stance to whether a change will be made here?
This issue is getting ridiculous now and is very frustrating. As someone who has actively played arena for many years and been fortunate enough to have season wins for several successive seasons, I now struggle get a game since many other active players have just added red thumbs to prevent matches and losses.
Arena is going down the route where it's not going to be the best player in games with less players but the one that plays the system which is wrong
This issue is getting ridiculous now and is very frustrating. As someone who has actively played arena for many years and been fortunate enough to have season wins for several successive seasons, I now struggle get a game since many other active players have just added red thumbs to prevent matches and losses.
Arena is going down the route where it's not going to be the best player in games with less players but the one that plays the system which is wrong
Agregar a este informe
Por favor agrega aquí cualquier cosa que sea relevante para reproducir este error o entender tu sugerencia:
- Otro ID de partida / ID de jugada
- ¿Se resolvió el problema al pulsar F5?
- ¿Apareció el problema varias veces? ¿Cada vez? ¿Aleatoriamente?
- Si tienes una captura de este error (buena práctica), puedes usar Imgur.com para subirla y copiar/pegar el enlace aquí.
