Todos los informes
Informes de Metromania
#61829: "Scoring Error, missing destination should be considered before missing station"
notupdated: Este informe se ha cerrado automáticamente porque no ha habido ningún voto/comentario durante mucho tiempo.
2
¿Sobre qué es este informe?
¿Qué ha pasado? Por favor, selecciona una de las opciones siguientes
Reglas: una regla del juego no ha sido respetada
Descripción detallada
-
• ¿Qué parte de las reglas no se ha respetado en la adaptación de BGA?
missing destination should be considered before missing station.
Red didn't place his E destination at all.
Orange place his E destination, but no station.
In this case, Red should be responsible for the incomplete route, and get -6 points (or orange & blue get +6 points in BGA adaptation).
However, the game thinks both Red & Orange are responsible, and have both Red & Orange have -6 points (only blue gets +6 points).
This does not follow the rules.
-
• ¿La infracción de las reglas es visible en la repetición de la partida? Si es así, ¿en qué jugada?
Yes, in final scoring.
• ¿Qué navegador estás usando?
Google Chrome v99
Historial de informes
27 Mar 2022 17:53 • FeedMeHealthRelic • Los desarrolladores aún no han podido reproducir el error:
screenshot:
imgur.com/a/cSbIhNU
imgur.com/a/cSbIhNU
27 Mar 2022 20:04 • diamant • Los desarrolladores aún no han podido reproducir el error:
The E destination test is not possible, and the red and orange players are both at fault, and should each receive a penalty of -6 points.
The blue player should not score anything, but scoring 6 points is equivalent to removing 6 points from each of the other players. I suppose this is a peculiarity of the implementation of Metromania on BGA.
As your report does not concern this peculiarity, but claims that the orange player should score 6 points, I would say that not only is it contrary to the rule, but on the form you do not even quote the rule point that you claim to apply, and it makes you wonder if you’ve read the rule.
Not a bug.
The blue player should not score anything, but scoring 6 points is equivalent to removing 6 points from each of the other players. I suppose this is a peculiarity of the implementation of Metromania on BGA.
As your report does not concern this peculiarity, but claims that the orange player should score 6 points, I would say that not only is it contrary to the rule, but on the form you do not even quote the rule point that you claim to apply, and it makes you wonder if you’ve read the rule.
Not a bug.
4 May 2022 10:53 • FeedMeHealthRelic • Los desarrolladores aún no han podido reproducir el error:
I am not querying about blue.
Quote from rule book:
"- If the destination marker was never placed on the board,
the guilty party is the player who didn't place the marker.
- If the marker was placed but nobody put a station touching
it, the guilty party is the player who placed the destination.
- If the markers were both placed, but no route exists
between the two, both players who placed the markers
are guilty."
Note the first rule, "the guilty party is the player who didn't place the marker".
This should take precedent over the second rule, but in the BGA implementation, it doesn't.
This is a bug / wrong implementation of the rule.
Quote from rule book:
"- If the destination marker was never placed on the board,
the guilty party is the player who didn't place the marker.
- If the marker was placed but nobody put a station touching
it, the guilty party is the player who placed the destination.
- If the markers were both placed, but no route exists
between the two, both players who placed the markers
are guilty."
Note the first rule, "the guilty party is the player who didn't place the marker".
This should take precedent over the second rule, but in the BGA implementation, it doesn't.
This is a bug / wrong implementation of the rule.
14 May 2023 12:16 • Sourisdudesert • Este informe se ha cerrado automáticamente porque no ha habido ningún voto/comentario durante mucho tiempo.:
Report closed automatically because it has not been upvoted or commented for a while.
Your bug has probably been fixed already, or was linked to a temporary failure of BGA service.
In any case, when filling a bug report, make sure to have an explicit title linked to the incident (ex: with error message), so other players can recognize it and vote for it.
Your bug has probably been fixed already, or was linked to a temporary failure of BGA service.
In any case, when filling a bug report, make sure to have an explicit title linked to the incident (ex: with error message), so other players can recognize it and vote for it.
Agregar a este informe
Por favor agrega aquí cualquier cosa que sea relevante para reproducir este error o entender tu sugerencia:
- Otro ID de partida / ID de jugada
- ¿Se resolvió el problema al pulsar F5?
- ¿Apareció el problema varias veces? ¿Cada vez? ¿Aleatoriamente?
- Si tienes una captura de este error (buena práctica), puedes usar Imgur.com para subirla y copiar/pegar el enlace aquí.
